Hostility Toward Gifted Children

Bullying has been in the news lately, so I’ve decided to share my family’s experience with bullying in 2007.  Here’s  a little background on the situation:

Our son M is highly gifted.  He had been attending Kindercare since he was two-and-a-half. During the 2006-2007 school year, he began the year in the PreK classroom. After Winter break, the school decided to eliminate the PreK class, and place those students together with the three and four-year-olds.  The director decided to place M (who had been reading and doing basic arithmetic since before he was three) in the Kindergarten class instead. M had turned four just a few months before he was accelerated to Kindergarten.

M seemed to be doing fine in the Kindergarten class which he attended every morning for three hours.  Keep in mind that Kindergarten is not required in California, and there were no “graduation requirements” to be met in this class. Even if there had been, M would have met them. We paid for him to be in that class, and he did the work he was given in that class.  He participated with the rest of the kindergarteners learning a song for their end-of-year party and graduation. The teacher ordered cute little caps and gowns for the kids to wear for their ceremony, and M was excited to wear his.


About a week before the party, I found this note in M’s cubby (names have been changed to protect the kids.)

Dear “M’s Parents”,

My name is Jack Hill. I’m Greg Hill’s father. I’m not sure if you know Greg. I know I’ve never met M.

Greg and Karl have been attending Kindercare since 2001, starting as babies just after the school opened. They’ve been here longer than any Kindercare employee. Brian and Nate started just a year or so later.

This Friday marks a completion for them—for Greg and Karl more so than the others. Greg and Karl will be the first children to complete a full course at this school. As tradition dictates, we mark that completion with a ceremony, including ceremonial garb and a certificate.

We do that to indicate and savor the accomplishment. We give the children a sense of achievement to carry with them in their new beginning as First Graders. We in turn are rewarded with a pride different from all the other feelings of pride we’ve felt for our child. This completion marks the beginning of our pride in watching our child become an adult.

My son tells me M will participate in the ceremony, but will not really graduate because he’s really just visiting Kindergarten. He wonders if that is right—and so do I.

Several of the kindergarten parents have asked themselves and each other the same question.

The children know that M is not really in their class. They know he won’t really be in kindergarten until next year. They know he hasn’t accomplished everything that they have. They know that when he participates in their graduation it will be pretend.

I would like you to know that your charade trivializes not only my child’s accomplishment or the other kindergartener’s, but yours as well—next year, when the accomplishment will be real. I began this letter with the intent to threaten and coerce you into doing what I think is right, but now I realize that perhaps you just didn’t know there’s really more to this ceremony than just dressing up. Perhaps you didn’t know that it had meaning for all of us.

I respectfully ask you to consider what this moment really means to you and your son. I ask you to weigh that value against tainting our children’s graduation.

I ask you simply to understand that you will be demonstrating reward for cheating to the entire 2007 kindergarten class by having your child participate in this graduation ceremony without basis.

I am asking you not to do that.


Jack Hill

Now you might say that the author of this letter is obviously crazy, and should simply be ignored. However, I was concerned by the “threaten and coerce” line.  The idea that another parent (whom I had never met!) could harbor so much hostility toward my family was frightening.  My husband and I brought the letter to the director of the school who said she would talk to this parent.  Unfortunately, after talking to him she was so intimidated that she asked us not to attend the party!  We were frightened enough that we decided it wasn’t worth it to insist.  Four years later, I still feel a twinge of fear when I encounter the families named in the letter in the community.

School administrators need to be aware of hostility toward gifted students, and stand up to parents who bully other families.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Hostility Toward Gifted Children

  1. C A says:

    I know how you feel. Happened to me as well…and instead of blaming the guilty parties they blame the innocent child…people really need to work on their fear of smart people…I hope you’ve taken him out of that school…

  2. Stefanie says:

    I understand that this is sick and scary for your kid, but LOL@accomplishments!!! It’s Kindergarten! Even if he was just visiting for fun (I know a kid who does – he’s too young but he tags along with his grandma who teaches there), just let him join in, who cares? It actualy *is* trivial. BTW your child looks adorable.

  3. I understand why you are afraid. But your child earned the right to be in the graduation. Only you know how bad these families really are ,so your judgment is best. I feel for your family, mine has been through similar things all my life. Best wishes for your child’s future.

  4. OMG. That is absolutely heartbreaking. Instead of feeling fear, try feeling sadness because people like that honestly have no clue what it’s like to be your child or your family. I am so sorry that you had to endure their ignorance and hope that along the way you remember that your child DESERVED to be in that class as he could meet the requirements and I hope that those families someday learn their ignorance and hurtfulness was wrong.

  5. Rebecca says:

    Your child did all the work their child did. The only reason your child was put in the kindergarten was because they already knew what the other children needed another year to learn. I am sad for you and sad for the children of those other families. What a horrible lesson they have taught them.
    Your child deserved to go to that party. I understand that you have to live around these people so sometimes you have to pick your battles. Knowing what you know it was good your son was not moving forward with those children. Sad.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s